Arnold's Sales Tax Proposal

by Robert in Monterey [courtesy of Calitics - Front Page]

A few months late and several billion dollars short, Arnold has finally gotten around to making a serious revenue proposal - a 1 cent increase in the sales tax for a duration of three years. The SacBee reports this is expected to raise around $4 to $5 billion.

Not one to offer a solution without strings, Arnold insists that this would only happen in exchange for "long-term budget fixes" such as a rainy-day fund. A rainy day fund is a good idea but that needs to come AFTER we fix the structural  revenue shortfall.

The problem with Arnold's proposal is that as most people recognize, sales taxes are a very regressive form of taxation. The Democrats' tax plan would have relied on income and corporate taxes and would have generated nearly $10 billion in revenue, greatly easing the current crisis.

Instead Arnold, in typical fashion, thinks the poor and working Californians should suffer for the budget to be fixed. A smaller sales tax increase might not be a bad idea, but income and corporate taxes are the better solution, as those kind of tax increases promote more economic growth and provide more stability for state revenues. Another solution would be sales tax modernization, where goods and services currently exempt would be included to reflect a 21st century economy. That would provide more stable revenues while also spreading the burden out more fairly.

Democrats are in a stronger position than they realize on this. The public wants smart, effective solutions on the budget, and they want their services to be protected. Let's hope they stick to those values.

PS: John Chiang tears yet another hole in Arnold's ridiculous wage and jobs cut: the state does NOT actually face a cash crisis, Chiang told a Senate committee. Chiang is emerging as a hero on this, and Arnold's attack on the workers is being revealed for the shock doctrine-style assault on wages and jobs that many of us always suspected it to be.