High Speed Rail and Public Private Partnerships in California: A Shotgun Wedding?

[courtesy of California Progress Report]

By Robert Cruickshank

This has been published on my new California High Speed Rail blog.

As those of you who have been reading me for the last year know, I love high speed rail. And you'd also know that I am deeply skeptical - to put it mildly - of public private partnerships (P3). So what am I to do when they are joined together in a shotgun wedding? From a press release put out by the California High Speed Rail Authority:

"California High-Speed Rail Authority Executive Director Mehdi Morshed, joined Governor Schwarzenegger Tuesday in participating in a roundtable discussion at the State Capitol regarding the importance of investing in California's infrastructure and maintaining the state's economic growth through public private partnerships.

"Mr. Morshed noted the California proposed system of high-speed trains offers a unique opportunity to develop a new model for "P3" or public private partnership financing....

"Mr. Morshed noted that high-speed trains are attractive to private investors because California's proposed system will bring a $1 billion annual profit or surplus, once built."

Now it's not as if this is totally new. The 2002 Implementation Plan always envisioned that private financing would play some sort of role in the HSR project, although at the time it was expected to be limited to the bonds.

But what exactly is meant by "private financing" - and how bad might this really be for HSR? The Authority's finance team anticipates public-private partnership opportunities will include project debt financing, vendor financing, system operations and private ownership.

I can live with private involvement in debt and vendor financing, even though government can always borrow more cheaply. System operations is iffy at best - government runs the French, Spanish, German, and Japanese lines quite well, and when system operations were privatized in Britain, the results were deadly. Private ownership, however, is a line we must not cross - public ownership of infrastructure is key to an effective, safe, and affordable transportation system for Californians. High speed rail is an economic catalyst and an environmental and sustainablity necessity. It needs to be held in public hands for public uses, and not hollowed out for private profit.