It’s Official - California’s Death Penalty is a Multi-Million Dollar Failure. Now What?

[courtesy of California Progress Report]

By Natasha Minsker

A panel of experts, including 10 law enforcement officers and prosecutors, unanimously agrees that California’s death penalty is utterly broken. To fix it, we’ll need to spend over $200 million per year. The current failed system already costs over $137 million more each year than our alternative of permanent imprisonment. Today’s report forces all Californians to ask: how much we are willing to pay for our death penalty when we have an alternative that punishes criminals and protects our communities without making us bankrupt?

According to the California Commission on the Fair Administration of Justice – a bi-partisan blue ribbon panel created by the California Senate in 2004, which just issued the first ever comprehensive report on the state’s death penalty system – we have three options for dealing with our death penalty crisis.

First, if we decide that we simply can’t part with a system that we now know drains critical resources from public safety budgets, puts innocent lives at risk, harms murder victim family members, and is applied unfairly, then we need to commit to spending over $200 million in tax dollars every year to make the system operational on the most basic levels.

The Commission estimates that in order to make the system function, we would have to spend nearly $100 million more each year to pay for more prosecution and defense lawyers, and more court staff to handle the enormous volume of death penalty cases and appeals. When you add that to the money we already spend, it totals $217 million a year. On top of that, the State Auditor recently concluded that it will cost almost $400 million to build a new death row housing facility at San Quentin, on ground that is literally sinking into the sea.

Considering California’s fiscal crisis, spending all of this money is not only unlikely, it’s impossible.